What will you learn from the article?
- What are the most important factors to consider when choosing an e-commerce platform?
- What questions should you ask to determine your business needs?
- What are the advantages and disadvantages of dedicated platforms compared to SaaS solutions?
- What features and capabilities should be key when choosing a platform?
- What security aspects should be taken into account?
Choosing an e-commerce platform is crucial for creating and developing an e-business. With dozens of solutions available on the market (both OS, SaaS, and dedicated), this article explores the different types of e-commerce platforms and highlights the key factors to consider when investing in a specific engine.
Types of e-commerce platforms
There are three main types of e-commerce platforms:
- Open source solutions
- SaaS (Software as a Service) solutions
- dedicated solutions
In this section, we'll focus on analyzing the first two (OS and SaaS). Below, we present the main differences between them.
Open Source in e-commerce
→ Access to source code: Open source software allows access to the source code, which allows users to freely customize and modify the application according to their needs.
→ Control and flexibility: Users have full control over their e-commerce environment, allowing them to customize features, add new modules, and tailor the store's appearance to suit their needs.
→ Costs and maintenance: Free versions of open-source software are often available, but using them largely requires programming skills to install, configure, and maintain. Costs can arise from customization, hosting, and technical support.
→ Ease of implementation: Implementing open source software can be more time-consuming (and this is the case in the vast majority of projects), especially for people without programming experience who outsource the implementation to an external organization.
→ Updates and support: Open source software updates typically require manual installation by the user. Technical support may be available from the community or for a fee.
→ Scalability: Scaling an open-source store may require more attention and resources, especially as traffic and transactions increase.
SaaS in e-commerce:
→ Source Code Access: In SaaS, the source code is typically not publicly available. Users receive a ready-to-use solution, with no option for deeper modifications to the code itself.
→ Control and flexibility: While SaaS offers ease of use, flexibility and control over the environment can be somewhat limited, as users typically rely on pre-built features provided by the vendor. However, it's important to note that implementing any type of change is generally less time-consuming than with projects based on open-source e-commerce platforms.
→ Costs and maintenance: The SaaS subscription model involves monthly or annual fees. Many SaaS providers handle hosting, maintenance, updates, and technical support, which can significantly reduce the need to hire an IT team.
→ Ease of implementation: SaaS platforms offer ready-made solutions that are typically easy to implement. Users can quickly start selling online without the need for a complex setup process.
→ Updates and support: SaaS providers automatically manage updates and typically offer technical support as part of the subscription.
→ Scalability: SaaS e-commerce platform providers often offer the flexibility to adapt subscription plans to changing business needs. Scaling is typically much easier than with an operating system.
Choosing between open source and SaaS in e-commerce depends on many factors, such as technical sophistication, budget, customization needs, control over the source code, and flexibility in managing your online store.
The most popular open source platforms
There are many popular open source e-commerce platforms used by businesses of all levels and in various industries. Here are a few of the most popular:
-
Magento:
- It's one of the most advanced and popular open-source e-commerce platforms. It offers rich functionality, scalability, and flexibility. Magento has a large user base, which means access to numerous extensions and community resources.
-
WooCommerce:
- It's an e-commerce plugin for WordPress, making it a popular choice for those already using the platform to manage their websites. WooCommerce is relatively easy to use and offers a wide range of extensions.
-
OpenCart:
- An open-source e-commerce platform with a simple administration interface, OpenCart is intuitive to install and configure, making it particularly popular among small and medium-sized businesses.
-
PrestaShop:
- This free e-commerce software offers a wide range of features and modules. PrestaShop is known for its intuitive interface and flexibility in customizing the appearance and functionality of your store.
-
Drupal Commerce:
- It's based on the Drupal platform, making it a good choice for those already using Drupal as their content management system (CMS). Drupal Commerce offers a wealth of customization and expansion options.
-
Sylius:
- A modern headless e-commerce platform based on PHP and Symfony, Sylius focuses on flexibility and modularity, allowing users to customize their store to their individual needs.
The most popular SaaS platforms
The most popular SaaS e-commerce platforms are widely used by entrepreneurs and businesses looking to easily manage their online stores without the need for technical infrastructure. Below is a list of some popular SaaS e-commerce platforms:
-
Shopify:
- One of the most popular SaaS platforms in e-commerce. It offers simple, feature-rich setup and access to a variety of templates, allowing you to easily create online stores without extensive programming skills. However, if you're looking to expand your store and implement new solutions, see how we can help. Shopify agency . Currently, over 4,000,000 online stores worldwide rely on this engine.
-
BigCommerce:
- A SaaS e-commerce platform focused on scalability. It offers advanced features such as multi-channel support, marketing tools, and the flexibility to customize your store's appearance.
-
Wix eCommerce:
- Wix is a platform that was originally popular as a website builder. It now also offers e-commerce features, allowing you to easily build and manage an online store.
-
Shopper :
- A solution that enjoys great popularity on the Polish market, Shoper is an e-commerce platform that offers all the necessary elements and integrations to run an online store in Poland.
-
Sky-Shop :
- Sky-Shop is an e-commerce engine that has integrations with popular marketplaces – Allegro, Empik, Ceneo, and has also gained popularity thanks to its dropshipping module.
Dedicated platforms
At the beginning of this article, we mentioned three types of e-commerce platforms. Having discussed the key issues related to open source and SaaS, it's time to discuss dedicated platforms. These are solutions designed to meet specific industry needs and requirements. They are often tailored to specific sectors or business types, allowing for more precise management of an online store. Here are some important facts about dedicated e-commerce platforms:
Specialization in specific industries: Dedicated platforms are often optimized for a specific industry. For example, there are dedicated solutions for the apparel, food, automotive, or electronics industries. This means they offer specialized features and tools tailored to the unique needs of each sector.
Advanced features and integrations: These platforms often offer advanced features that are essential for specific industries. These include warehouse management tools, reporting systems, integration with ERP (Enterprise Resource Planning) systems, and advanced personalization features.
Scalability: Dedicated platforms are designed with scalability in mind to adapt to business growth and evolution. This means they can support small, medium, and large enterprises.
Support and customization: They often offer dedicated support for their clients, which may include implementation assistance, training, or the availability of dedicated technical support staff. Furthermore, dedicated platforms can be flexible in terms of adapting to specific client needs.
Security and Compliance: Because they serve a variety of industries, dedicated platforms typically meet high security standards and comply with industry regulations. This is especially important in areas with specific data protection requirements.
Long product life cycle: Dedicated platforms often have a long product lifecycle, meaning they are developed and updated over a long period of time. This ensures stability and continued support for customers.
When choosing a dedicated e-commerce platform, it is important to understand the specifics of your business, industry needs, and carefully analyze the features, integrations, support availability, and costs associated with a given solution.
While dedicated e-commerce platforms offer many benefits, there are also some potential drawbacks worth considering when choosing the right solution. Here are some of the downsides associated with dedicated platforms:
-
High costs:
- One of the main drawbacks of dedicated platforms is their typically high cost. Implementing, customizing, and maintaining such a solution can be significantly more expensive than using off-the-shelf SaaS platforms.
-
Long implementation time:
- Implementing a dedicated platform can be time-consuming. Adapting to specific business requirements, integrating with existing systems, testing, and customizing to meet company needs can take many months.
-
Complicated update:
- Managing and maintaining a dedicated platform can be complex. Software updates, error handling, and adapting to industry changes can require specialized knowledge and experience. Some dedicated platforms may not receive regular updates, which can lead to a loss of compliance with new industry standards, increase security risks, and impede the use of new features.
-
No immediate availability:
- Ready-made SaaS platforms are typically ready to use immediately after registration. However, dedicated platforms can take a significant amount of time to implement, potentially delaying the launch of your e-commerce business.
-
Risk of loss of technical team availability:
- For dedicated platforms, the availability of a development team or IT specialists can be crucial. If such a team is difficult to recruit or leaves the company, this can impact the platform's maintenance and development.
-
Smaller community and ecosystem:
- Compared to popular open source or SaaS platforms, dedicated platforms may have a smaller user base. This can impact the availability of extensions, modules, and community support.
-
Less flexibility in scaling:
- While dedicated platforms are often scalable, the scaling process can be more complex than with some SaaS platforms, which are designed to be flexible and quickly adapt to business growth.
Some dedicated platforms may not receive regular updates, which may lead to a loss of compliance with new industry standards, increase security risks, and make it difficult to use new features.
Before choosing a dedicated e-commerce platform, it is important to thoroughly understand the business needs, analyze the costs and benefits, and consider whether a more general, ready-to-use platform would meet the company's expectations.
Choosing the right e-commerce platform
Below are some questions worth asking yourself when choosing an e-commerce platform. They can be considered a step-by-step guide to choosing the right solution.
1. Do you want to sell only locally or globally?
By answering this question, you will classify whether you need a solution only for the domestic market or, looking ahead, also for foreign markets.
2. Are you planning to sell products or services?
Knowing the different product types will make it easier to choose a specific platform. Understanding the purchasing process for non-physical products (and how these orders are handled) will be crucial here.
3. What budget do you want to allocate for the e-commerce platform?
This is one of the key questions that will truly determine the size of the project. Defining the budget allows for a tailored solution—a less expensive SaaS solution or a more expensive open source/custom solution. The solution selection will also define the project's timeline.
4. What features and capabilities do I need?
Here, you should focus on all the elements you expect from an e-commerce platform. An advanced search engine? A comprehensive customer dashboard? A specific product page? It's worth verifying which components of benchmark stores are important and which will be necessary to implement.
5. Do I want to host the store myself or use the platform's hosting services?
By answering this question, you will get a clear answer as to which direction to go – OS or SaaS.
6. What are my technical skills?
You need to realistically consider the human resources at your disposal. OS will require specialists (often in-house), while SaaS allows for much greater flexibility. Do you value the ability to quickly respond to changes in the e-commerce environment? Do you want to modify many things yourself? SaaS will be a better solution for you.
7. What additional costs should I pay attention to?
You should consider all costs beyond the project budget itself – applications, extensions, integrations, external systems, but also commission costs (e.g. % of orders using specific payment gateways).
8. What integrations and extensions do you want to use?
As seen in question number 7, you should take into account the costs associated with additional elements, but the most important thing is to realistically assess what integrations will be required – ERP, CRM, PIM (you can learn why a PIM system is so important in an enterprise by reading the article in our knowledge zone )? Baselinker?
9. What support and technical documentation does the platform provide?
This is also a crucial issue that shouldn't be overlooked. If you're committed to developing a platform, you should be able to verify its documentation and gain insight into development plans – how the e-commerce platform your e-business will be built on evolves also has a real impact on your development.
10. Does the platform meet security standards such as PCI DSS?
The security of your customers, their data, and the information stored in your store is crucial. When choosing an e-commerce platform, security should be a key factor.
When choosing an e-commerce platform, it's important to carefully consider many factors to identify the solution that best suits your business's needs and goals. In summary, pay attention to the following elements:
-
Type and scale of business:
- Determine whether you need a platform for a small, medium, or large enterprise. Some platforms are more scalable and focused on specific business types (e.g., B2B only, B2C only, B2B & B2C). You should also consider whether you want omnichannel sales.
-
Store functionalities:
- Check if the platform offers features that are crucial to your business, such as product management, shopping cart, payment integrations, marketing tools, reporting systems, etc.
-
Ease of use and user interface:
- Choose a platform with an intuitive and easy-to-use interface. This is important, especially if you don't have much experience managing an online store.
-
Customization, flexibility and personalization:
- Make sure the platform allows you to customize your store's appearance to suit your individual needs and brand. Flexibility in customizing and expanding features is crucial for business evolution.
-
The cost of running an online store
- Analyze the platform's pricing model, paying attention not only to upfront costs but also to fees related to maintenance, transaction processing, and customization. Compare the costs of different platforms to find the most cost-effective solution.
-
Technical support:
- Check the platform's support options. Are there different support plans available? Is there a user community where you can get help?
-
Security:
- Customer data security is crucial. Ensure your platform has appropriate security measures and meets industry security standards.
-
Integrations with external tools:
- Check if the platform integrates with tools you already use or plan to use, such as ERP systems, marketing tools, data analytics, or payment systems.
-
Scalability:
- Consider whether the platform is scalable enough to grow with your business. Will it easily adapt to an increased number of products, transactions, or new features?
-
Opinions and reviews:
- Read the opinions and reviews of other entrepreneurs using the platform. This can provide valuable insight into other users' experiences.
-
Mobile availability:
- In the era of mobile shopping, pay attention to whether the platform offers responsive design and whether it provides easy access to the online store on various mobile devices.
Gaining a full understanding of these aspects will help you make an informed choice of e-commerce platform for your business.
Summary
- Upgrade Complexity: Managing a dedicated platform may require specialized knowledge.
- Availability: SaaS platforms are ready to use out of the box, while dedicated platforms require time to implement.
- Technical Team: Difficulties in accessing the development team may affect the development of a dedicated platform.
- Community: Less community support compared to popular open source or SaaS platforms.
- Scalability: The scaling process on dedicated platforms can be more complicated.
- Security: Ensure the platform meets security standards such as PCI DSS.
- Functionalities: Identify key features that are essential to your business, such as product management or payment integration.
- Budget: Define a financial framework to align your platform selection with your expectations.
- Customization: Choose a platform that allows for personalization and easy changes.
